18:00:04 #startmeeting 18:00:04 Meeting started Wed Jan 15 18:00:04 2020 UTC. The chair is DLange. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 18:00:04 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic. 18:00:11 #chair gwolf 18:00:11 Current chairs: DLange gwolf 18:00:16 #chair tumbleweed 18:00:16 Current chairs: DLange gwolf tumbleweed 18:00:24 #chair terceiro 18:00:24 Current chairs: DLange gwolf terceiro tumbleweed 18:00:47 Hello and welcome to the first DebConf21 bid review meeting! 18:00:52 #topic role call 18:01:01 * nattie waves hi 18:01:04 please state your name and which bid / team you are here for 18:01:11 nattie is here for the hi team 18:01:26 * h01ger is here as ghostwatcher 18:01:48 Hello o/ I am here for the "hi team" as well. 18:01:54 * gwolf is here watching for ghosts 18:02:05 Hi, here as part of bid committee 18:02:10 #chair indiebio_ 18:02:10 Current chairs: DLange gwolf indiebio_ terceiro tumbleweed 18:02:22 * srud[m]1 is here for India 18:02:25 * tzafrir here as well 18:02:32 hi, Kosovo here 18:02:36 calhariz with Diana for the Portugal Bid 18:02:43 filiperfernandes for the Portugal bid 18:02:44 * akhvar here for India 18:02:45 * PiratePraveen[m] here for India 18:02:52 * terceiro part of the DebConf committee 18:02:57 * tumbleweed is here from the committee, too 18:03:10 * DLange is part of the DebConf committee, too 18:03:13 Hi to all too 18:03:30 * gwolf is DC committee as well 18:03:58 *rajudev for India 18:04:29 welcome everybody! 18:04:57 We'll go through each of the bids now. India first due to timezones. 18:05:24 Please introduce your bid and say a few words about what you are proud of and what needs improvement. 18:05:33 Then we open for questions on each of the bids. 18:05:40 #topic Bid from India 18:05:48 your floor, team India 18:06:17 * paddatrapper joins the hi team 18:06:30 India is one of the most culturally and geographically diverse nations in the world. Kochi, bid venue, is known as the financial, commercial and industrial capital of Kerala, southern state of India. We have an active Debian community in India, organizing big and small events throughout the year, from Mini-DebConfs, DebUtsavs, Debian Release Parties to Packaging Workshops, we have all types of events and DebConf in India will be a natural 18:06:30 step forward. We have 4 DDs and 6+ team members in and around Kochi alone to deal with all local arrangements. With a lower cost of living in India, we can have a great Debconf with smaller budget. 18:07:08 We are proud of the active team behind this bid. 18:07:09 #link https://wiki.debian.org/DebConf/21/Bids/India 18:07:17 #link https://wiki.debian.org/DebConf/21/Bids/India/CheckList 18:08:39 FTR 71,400 USD is quite normal for a DebConf (before bursary budget) 18:08:50 so you probably planned good food and good accommodation?!? 18:09:06 srud[m]1: Please try to fill what DLange asked - What do you think (in general, as well as compared to the other teams) the main strengths and weaknesses of your bid 18:09:11 The biggest challenge we think for our bid is the climate. The preferred time would be September-December which seems to be out of regular Debconf timing 18:09:35 it would be an option, though 18:09:40 This is including bursary 18:09:50 we are not strictly bound to Western summer 18:09:50 We have found good hotels 18:09:55 Right - I was surprised to find that the monthly rainfall in Jun-Jul-Aug is near the yearly rainfall for my region - which is by no means desertic :-( 18:10:01 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kochi#Climate 18:10:43 DLange: Moving away from the Northern summer is, yes, an option - but it has a bit of a feasibiliy cost. 18:11:10 yes, but if it is too warm and wet in Kochi ... seems like a good idea 18:11:10 looked at 3 start hotels, but could go for 4 or 5 star if we can go more than what we currently budgeted 18:11:37 also some people are always at odds with us hitting summer school holidays every time, so I'd be in favor 18:11:42 3 star sounds about right (on the high end, even) 18:11:51 I suspect that in retrospect people would have appreciated it if Cape Town was not in mid-winter. Was less of an issue for Curitiba 18:11:55 but we need to make sure to not collide with other (important) conferences 18:12:25 DLange, we will have good food for all food choice preferences.( Answering your second question) 18:12:30 @team india: what about the venue in September-December? 18:12:55 food we have good options 18:13:12 if we can confirm an year in advance, it should be perfectly fine. 18:13:45 team india: Who in your team is based in Kochi vs elsewhere in India? 18:13:47 In the bid you mention several hotels in the center, and if I understand correctly, you plan on not only accomodating, but splitting the activities between the rooms in different hotels. Could you share a map pin-pointing the places so we can better estimate distances and movements? (of course, not for immediatE) 18:13:55 no university non-break issues or so to be expected within the team? 18:14:24 #action share a map pin-pointing the places for conference halls, hacklabs and accommodation 18:14:25 sure, will give one 18:14:38 *rajudev based in Delhi, far from kochi 18:15:04 srud[m]1: OK, please mention so in the bid ("Downsides - Not one campus event as it will be spread across 2 or more hotels" leads to understanding differently) 18:15:11 no.. none of us are in universities or academics 18:15:19 thanks srud[m]1 18:15:26 tumbleweed Abhijith, Balasankar very near to Kochi 18:15:37 Akhil is 2 hours from Kochi, Kannan, Amabady, Ranjith an hour from Kochi 18:15:53 so any of you please pick the action from above^ :) 18:15:58 me and srud 5 hours from Kochi 18:16:03 any other questions, feedback on the Indian bid? 18:16:06 Kiran 2 hours from Kochi 18:16:08 as I understood from the checklist, it seems like the conference facilities only charges per person for the meals, but not for renting the space itself. is that accurate? 18:16:13 Many of the local team is near kochi 18:16:36 Are the venues or accommodation in any way affected by university non-breaks? 18:17:10 Regarding living "near Kochi" - What matters most here is, how many among you _know their way_ in Kochi, specifically where we will be working, so we can find things easily when needed 18:17:29 yes, they charge either per head meal for total people or 40% of the venue capacity whichever is higher 18:18:35 Atleast 10 of us are very familiar with Kochi including organizing events 18:18:56 gwolf majority of team members are familiar with Kochi 18:19:03 I'll take some notes on your answers as #info 18:19:10 Please correct me if I'm mistaken 18:19:26 #info At least 10 team members very familiar with Kochi, have organized events 18:19:27 nope.. all are commercial hotels 18:20:02 #info We will probably split between hotels for accomodation, but venue would be in a single hotel 18:20:18 ah, I misunderstood that in the doc 18:20:38 #info Team suggests conference to be in Sep-Dec, due to better weather 18:20:54 Thanks, then I am in favour of different dates to accommodate the climate 18:21:13 if the accomodation will be in different hotels, what about the hacklab, will it be in one on the hotels or st the venue? 18:21:17 we may have to shift hacklab to a different hotel (500m distance) 18:21:44 #info Hacklab might need to be at a different hotel (500m distance) 18:21:59 (500m is nontrivial when ~>30°C humid) 18:22:00 just one hacklab then? 18:22:23 main concern here is restriction on beer.. the venue hotel does not have alcohol license 18:22:25 Committee - Please #info answers I've missed, mainly answers to your own questions 18:22:51 srud[m]1: Well, we are used to having beer on hacklab in the past few years, but I wouldn't say it's required. 18:22:57 It's a *very* welcome addition 18:23:02 but not required 18:23:16 srud[m]1: we'd usually need at least two hacklabs, a quiet one and a loud one (that may or may not have beer) 18:23:26 (essentially what gwolf said :)) 18:23:57 then I think we can accomodate hacklab in the same hotel as the venue..but need to check 18:24:08 # venue costs is per person, with a minimum of 40% of the capacity 18:24:19 #info venue costs is per person, with a minimum of 40% of the capacity 18:24:19 #action check at least two hacklabs in one hotel 18:24:41 #action check for alcohol license (not required but nice for noisy hacklab) 18:26:04 are we good on the Indian bid? 18:26:41 I think so 18:26:52 great, thanks then! 18:26:57 thanks for coming so late, team india 18:27:03 yeah thanks 18:27:10 please complete the action items for the next meeting 18:27:31 which will be in two weeks or so ... depending on the work amount we find in the other team's bids :) 18:27:36 thank you all :) 18:27:37 any other questions for now or next meeting? 18:27:43 okay 18:27:50 you are free to leave and get a nap if you need to be working early tomorrow or just value your sleep :) 18:27:51 thanks everyone 18:27:55 thanks 18:27:58 Thanks for staying await so late :-] 18:28:06 Thanks 18:28:09 And keep an eye for whatever is said in the rest of the meeting 18:28:21 comments to one bidding team are usually worthy for all of them ;-) 18:29:30 #Bid from Kosovo 18:29:39 Kosovo team, the channel is yours 18:29:42 Kosovo is a good place to hold a DebConf since its Europe and both East and West will have it easier. The weather in July is comfortable 33 °C, humidity very low. The country is quite beautiful. Venue has a great structure that meets the needs of this conference, as I have seen in previous DebConfs. Sleeping place conditions are great, its near and has a big capability. Access to equipments and tech stuff is easy. WiFi connection everywhere. 18:29:43 Safety is pretty high. Many activities to have fun. Local team has a lot of experience in organizing tech events. The main problem is that its very early yet and we would get sponsorship and actual plans from sponsors only if we knew for sure the conference would happen here. 18:29:53 #topic Bid from Kosovo 18:30:33 thanks gwolf :) 18:30:42 Strengths and weaknesses compared to other bids? 18:31:04 strength is that the food place, venue and the sleeping place is all within 200m maximum 18:31:26 we have the capacity to host up to 4000 people 18:31:35 at the sleeping place 18:31:52 omg, that's a lot 18:31:54 alcohol is not a problem 18:32:05 we usually have it at every conference 18:32:06 what do you mean with "sponsorship and actual plans from sponsors" - just local sponsors at some level, or e.g. sponsorship of the venue etc.? 18:32:19 just local, aditional 18:32:24 ok, thanks 18:33:17 #info alcohol is not a problem, we usually have it at every conference *smirk* 18:33:20 enkelenaH: The proposal is quite impressive... but how *certain* are you we will get _all_ that's offered for free or very cheap? (I mean what yu say towards the end, "because the proposals need to be very serious and to surely happen") 18:33:35 I had a similar question 18:33:44 from my own experience; university venue in Curitiba was promised to us as being free, then relatively close to the conference layers got involved and it wasn't free anymore 18:34:56 Same happened to us in Cape town 18:35:18 As I have contacted the university they said that for this specificall conference they would give it to us. We should understand thaat this conference would be extremely important not like a usuall one here, so max support from the university and proffessors I spoke to 18:35:27 sorry for any typo 18:35:33 that sounds very nice 18:35:55 and I have spoken to the next Primeminister, he is a friend of mine 18:36:06 He said that they would support 18:36:30 That's great. Just to be sure could you find out what the normal hire costs would be, just to know in case? 18:36:36 ... they vote in Kosovo 18:36:48 ... but enkelenaH knows the results up front :) 18:37:12 normal cost maybe up to 1000 for the whole conference but I will ask. People dont pay institutions to hold conferences there, we just get a permission 18:37:21 he won 18:37:22 haha 18:37:31 congrats 18:37:35 he has 15 days to take the chair 18:37:49 enkelenaH: The number you say for the dorms, €50, is it per person per night? Per person per two weeks? 18:37:56 per person per 2 weeks 18:38:19 I see an issue with your bid in the (secured) capacity of people available. How sure are you, Albiona, Diellza etc. that you will be available for organizing such a big conference? 18:38:21 at this time is this price, maybe we can take it for cheaper 18:38:28 like jobs, university etc. 18:38:44 enkelenaH: Cheaper, they'd have to pay us :-] 18:38:46 #info €50 dorm cost per person per 2 weeks 18:39:16 we have other people ssupporting us, organizations, ngo's its not just us. Voulenteers whom I have spoken to 18:39:31 for those who care about prime ministers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prime_Minister_of_Kosovo (a bit outdated but has the names) 18:39:31 that should be listed explicitly in the bid page IMO 18:39:32 but this is the official people 18:39:39 Albin Kurti 18:39:42 should be haha 18:39:50 right :) 18:39:53 we shall call him Albin :) 18:40:05 thhey are calling him Mr.Bin 18:40:10 could you answer my question on availability? 18:40:59 I am completely sure, they are sure, we have already spoken about this to other people aand held some non official meetings 18:41:27 it's good to get stuff in writing, though 18:41:38 like a declaration 18:41:43 aabout our availability? 18:41:52 nattie: Although usually we will get it in writing only if the bid wins 18:42:00 gwolf: *nods* indeed 18:42:01 either a booking, or a letter of intent 18:42:08 but yeah, usually only after winning 18:42:14 #info team is sure to be available 18:42:23 and motivated 18:42:38 we don't doubt your motivation 18:43:36 you should not doubt the availability either, because we are commited to this 18:44:07 great, thank you. Would you consider applying for DD status? We have a stortcoming in DDs in your bid. Like zero currently in the core team. 18:44:33 DLange: Although we have had DebConf with no local DDs... 18:44:34 DC12 had no DD 18:44:36 It's not necessary 18:44:39 its important that we have the support of voulenteers from very successful NGOs with hunderds of voulneers 18:44:40 DC11 neither IIRC 18:44:54 dc9 neither 18:45:12 can I become a non uploading one? 18:45:13 gwolf: I have not said it is necessary, it is just nicer and legally we have some jurisdiction over DDs but not non-project members 18:45:15 wasnt adnan a dd already? plus me was heavily involved in dc9 and 12.. 18:45:32 (as in sign stuff on behalf of SPI etc.) 18:45:38 DD-ship (DD-ness?) is orthogonal. I'd love them to become DDs, but in no way would press them for applying because of DebConf 18:45:50 enkelenaH: Of course you can! 18:46:08 (if you feel like that and stuff...) 18:46:10 #info we may have found a future project member :) 18:46:25 then I will try to be one! starting in 30m heh 18:46:42 #diversity striking 18:46:59 (-: 18:47:12 #info the bid is the most non-diverse we have. Only women :) 18:47:39 fun aside ... could you to cost totals on your checklist section of the bid page, please? 18:47:46 *do cost totals 18:47:58 sure, will be ready until next meeting 18:48:15 great, thank you 18:48:28 #action add cost totals on the checklist section 18:49:14 I want to add that Kosovo is very small, compared to other places like Brazil. The local team lives within 10minutes from each other 18:49:28 I have received a private message questioning about the safety situation and infrastructure status (as in how good it is). Can you comment? 18:49:41 enkelenaH: $anycountry is small compared to Brazil, with a very high probability ;-) 18:50:25 no hate crimes like religion or sexual orientation, neither with other nationalities 18:50:35 i dont see something here that would make the place unsafe 18:50:57 no street shootings or the like? 18:51:01 (the bid link #info for Kosovo is missing I think) 18:51:04 never 18:51:12 #link https://wiki.debian.org/DebConf/21/Bids/Kosovo 18:51:15 the last ones should have been in 2001 18:51:16 thank you azeem 18:51:37 was Mr.Bin .. nah, I won't ask... 18:51:52 isnt that democracy? 18:52:02 Pristina airport looks well connected 18:52:14 Another Q: Why did the other members of the local team not join the meeting? 18:52:17 I guess most of us born in the 70s still have to shake the now-false violent image from ex-Yugoslavian states. 18:53:00 gunar: that really needs to happen. I guess this shows how small we are as a country, something happens and its kept in minds for 20-30 years 18:53:01 even after Banja Luka?? 18:53:09 because they are working now 18:53:21 azeem: The fact DLange received the question in private makes it clear 18:53:33 IMO 18:53:42 ack 18:54:04 I'm happy to relay if people are to shy to ask themselves. Questions can still be valid. 18:54:35 is there any question I did not answer, please point it out 18:54:36 of course, I don't mean to censor that in any way 18:55:08 19:53 < DLange> Another Q: Why did the other members of the local team not join the meeting? 18:55:12 enkelenaH: ^^ 18:55:17 ah 18:55:18 sorry, you did 18:55:21 nm 18:55:46 any other questions on the Kosovo bid? 18:56:37 maybe 18:56:54 want to ask now? 18:56:59 I only see two talk rooms listed in the bid. Are there more? 18:57:01 the main auditorium has 250 seats, what about keynotes opening/closing, do you think there will be less than 250 participiantes? 18:57:06 if you think I should add general information about the country please say so 18:57:15 its not as famous as INdia 18:57:22 yet, enkelenaH, yet 18:58:05 we can modify that for those special cases Azeem, we can find bigger ones but we'd need to walk like 500m 18:58:58 would be good to at least mention/explore those alternatives 18:59:20 500m seems to be a thing for DC21 :) 18:59:36 #action add larger talk room alternatives to the bid page 18:59:41 sure, I will, there are other alternatives but I thouht it be better if everything was in a short distance 19:00:01 give us the variants available, enkelenaH and we can discuss priorities 19:00:12 will do! 19:00:18 the video team can also relay sessions between rooms 19:00:33 just one big room for everybody is nice, too 19:00:40 ...provided they have good network between them... 19:00:44 but we only need it a few times during the week 19:00:49 (also, the video team never wants to have to do that) 19:01:02 tumbleweed is awesome at pulling fibres between rooms 19:01:04 Video team loves complaining ;-) 19:01:31 if people dont mind that distance, we have alternatives and I will add them, but the main auditoriums would be the ones I mentioned and sent pictures of 19:02:02 #info if people dont mind that distance, we have alternatives and I will add them, but the main auditoriums would be the ones I mentioned and sent pictures of 19:02:07 as per internet connection, especially on the venue, will you be covered? 19:02:17 enkelenaH: People will be happier to know we have an option - and probably will choose what you already suggested ;-) 19:02:41 yes it is already good covered as it is an insitute. The administration of UNiversity of Prishtina is located there and the university library 19:02:53 but if it is not enough we can easily modify 19:03:40 cool, thanks! 19:03:55 last call: more questions on the Kosovo bid? 19:04:58 cool. Thank you then! 19:05:20 #topic Bid from Portugal 19:05:29 thank you 19:05:36 Team Lisboa, the floor is yours 19:05:51 Hi 19:05:53 hi! 19:06:04 I am here with Diana and Filipe 19:06:08 Portugal is a beautiful country, very well located in west Europe, by the sea with a nice wheather. Venue would be at Técnico, one of the best engineering and technology universities in Portugal and Europe. The venue is supported by the head of the university, such as many other events that happened here before. It has good wifi coverage all over the campus with several areas for both work, relax 19:06:08 and eat. As you may have heard Portugal is known for its excellent gastronomy :) 19:07:06 how veggie/vegan-friendly would the catering be? 19:07:41 The main restaurante at venue now have a veggie dish every day 19:07:49 rice and beans :D 19:08:11 Several places inside the venue have veggie options 19:08:26 Around there specialized veggie places 19:08:47 And we have Brasilian restaurants if you want rice and beans 19:08:57 lol 19:09:06 *smirk* 19:09:14 * gwolf loves rice and beans. Today I had some already :-] 19:09:21 Can we have conservas de peixe instead? 19:09:34 DLange: you can, not so sure about the vegans 19:09:37 .oO( churascarias? ) 19:10:43 #info Omnivores are well covered, for vegans we have one dish a day in the main restaurant and specialized veggie places inside the venue 19:11:06 The specialzed places are around campus 19:11:11 Students at our campus are used to organise barbecues (churrascos) every beggining and end of semesters 19:11:20 calhariz: Are the "specialized places" within the same price range? 19:11:46 Around 7-10 euros 19:11:55 Given they are specialized... Can we have a way to eat everybody together, offering good options for non-omnivores? 19:12:08 for people who remember last year's bid, are there any significant changes since last year? 19:12:38 We are thinking in have everything cared by the same catter our a second specilized catter for veggie 19:13:02 or* 19:13:42 It is a continuation of the same bid. 19:13:53 +v <- more verbose please 19:14:27 We have more people, the Hotels should be the same, the venue is the same. 19:14:43 And new people joined the team :D 19:14:48 \o/ 19:14:56 awesome! 19:14:57 How confident are you in the multi-hotel option working for 4..500 attendees now? 19:15:33 We have made plans for around 350 people paid by Debian 19:15:40 #info continuation of DC20 bid, new people joined the team 19:16:08 I think we would need to have contingents for self-payers, too 19:16:19 so they don't end up on the remote part of town 19:16:20 But there are many Hotels and hostels near for the people that are self-payers 19:16:49 Around 500m there are many options 19:16:54 how sure are you about really having the conf. facilities for free? 19:17:03 Strengths and weaknesses compared to other bids? 19:17:55 The venue usually offer the space for non commercial events. 19:18:48 we have a new Head of University, so need to recheck. 19:19:17 you need to check whether they would still consider non-commercial an event with the likes of google and microsoft as sponsors 19:19:44 #action re-check free availability of venue with new Head of University 19:19:51 calhariz: If it's usual policy, I'd trust your judgement, but try having at least an informal talk with him (or some other person responsible for managing the facilities) soon! 19:20:03 OK 19:20:27 Again, and as I said to enkelenaH - I doubt we can get anything in writing before committing to a bid. But having an informal OK is important! 19:21:22 Strengths: Really good weather, specially on end of July until end of september; Gastronomy as mentioned before; Support of the IT team of the university; Good public (buses and subway) and private (Taxis,Uber and others) which makes everything closer 19:21:41 do you think we could get reserved contingents ("book mentioning DebConf for our rate") with hotels around the venue, too? 19:21:55 (like the ones we do not fill with sponsored attendees) 19:22:12 DLange: we tried last year, and the hotels didn't seem that keen to give a special rate 19:22:31 presumably we could get a guarantee, but possibly not better than market 19:22:36 I'm more interested in 200 reserved beds than special prices, tumbleweed 19:22:44 I think they said they'd do that 19:22:50 if we'd commit 19:22:52 ok, I missed that then 19:22:54 but I shouldn't be answering for the team 19:23:01 can you #info it? 19:23:12 calhariz: am I recalling correctly? 19:23:15 tunbleweed: It still true 19:23:40 #info hotels are willing to commit rooms to us (but not at much of a discount) 19:23:46 great 19:24:04 any other questions to the Portugal team? 19:24:19 Weaknesses: We would like to increase our team; Different places for accommodation even though they are close to each other; 19:25:06 how big is your core team now, filiperfernandes? As in the people that will work on DebConf at least one-two hours each and every week? 19:25:38 will there be many students using the university at that time or is it holidays? 19:26:37 7 people on the core working on the IT department and some interested students 19:26:46 thank you 19:27:21 During July and August it is holidays, so there just a few students, mostly working on their thesis 19:28:10 #info 7 people from the IT department commited to the core team, plus some students 19:28:29 #info July and August are holidays, few students will be at the unviersity 19:30:23 More questions? 19:31:36 doesn't look like it 19:31:40 Thank you to the bid teams. These are all strong bids and we appreciate your work so far. 19:31:53 #topic wrap up 19:32:04 * DLange includes indiebio_'s line here :) 19:32:36 I think we did not have too big issues identified that you could not work through in ~2 weeks, right? 19:33:24 Yes 19:33:45 I propose the next meeting Thurs, 30 Jan. Same time (sorry India!). Any issues with that? 19:34:47 Seams Good. 19:34:55 31 would be better for me as I am traveling for FOSDEM through that week and need to settle 19:34:58 but as you decide 19:35:03 Seems Goods. 19:35:10 31 is not good for me 19:35:26 okay no problem here then 19:35:31 I am going to FOSDeM too. 19:35:46 I am not :-( 19:35:55 it is fine for us .. 5 of India's core team will be in Europe/minidebcamp then 19:35:56 me neither, gwolf 19:36:05 awesome 19:36:47 #info DC21 bid review meeting #2 (probably final review meeting) on Jan 30, 18:00 UTC 19:36:48 Great, so having the meeting by next Thursday will allow all of you to go have some beers and celebrate the one winning ;-) 19:37:02 #endmeeting